+- McTopia Forum (http://forum.mctopia.us)
+-- Forum: General Forum (http://forum.mctopia.us/forumdisplay.php?fid=1)
+--- Forum: General Discussion (http://forum.mctopia.us/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Moral Dilemma (/showthread.php?tid=5056)
Moral Dilemma - Jamourous - 2014-03-15
Hey Guys and Gals!
I wanted to gauge opinions on this popular dilemma, and the actual yay/nay persuasion of the community we are all a part of.
The rule in question is: Specific time periods for griefing a certain structure.
I personally agree with this, and so do a few other members of the community, while others believe in the 'if you don't protect it, it's your fault' rule. I use it only on my Farnsworth Houses, which are becoming more common in the landscape (There's 4 of them now, and 1 under construction). Griefing one (because all but one are unprotected) will result in a 10x worse punishment, as I like these houses, and I want to trust the community to be able to see these houses without protection. I saw a sign the other day saying 'grief results in a 12 day jail', which was brought to my attention by Jake, who removed 2 blocks, and I was halfway through the jail command before he put them back.
Heres the question: Do you agree? Should other people be allowed to jail for that extended time period if the structure is not theirs? Opinions, please.
Keep building!
Jack
Moral Dilemma - challenger410 - 2014-03-15
In all honestly, I try not to be biased in jailing, whether it's my house, or some random guy who joined the server an hour before I logged on. I tend to look for more when it's my stuff being griefing, as opposed to just rolling back the other persons. I don't take lightly on griefing, which is why I usually grief, I say "You better hope you don't get caught by me", because I was a member for a very long time. I know how it feels to lose my stuff. I know how it feels having to rebuild time and time again, basically to the point to where you hide your home from everyone. I try to keep that off this server.
Moral Dilemma - Metazard - 2014-03-15
challenger410 wrote:In all honestly, I try not to be biased in jailing, whether it's my house, or some random guy who joined the server an hour before I logged on. I tend to look for more when it's my stuff being griefing, as opposed to just rolling back the other persons. I don't take lightly on griefing, which is why I usually grief, I say "You better hope you don't get caught by me", because I was a member for a very long time. I know how it feels to lose my stuff. I know how it feels having to rebuild time and time again, basically to the point to where you hide your home from everyone. I try to keep that off this server.
That hawkeye on my town 3 times tho
Moral Dilemma - challenger410 - 2014-03-15
Metazard wrote:challenger410 wrote:In all honestly, I try not to be biased in jailing, whether it's my house, or some random guy who joined the server an hour before I logged on. I tend to look for more when it's my stuff being griefing, as opposed to just rolling back the other persons. I don't take lightly on griefing, which is why I usually grief, I say "You better hope you don't get caught by me", because I was a member for a very long time. I know how it feels to lose my stuff. I know how it feels having to rebuild time and time again, basically to the point to where you hide your home from everyone. I try to keep that off this server.
That hawkeye on my town 3 times tho
Challengecraft. NewChallengecraft, End challengecraft. Bossville,
Moral Dilemma - mattjtv - 2014-03-15
challenger410 wrote:End challengecraft
D:
Moral Dilemma - Mcmanaway1 - 2014-03-15
challenger410 wrote:Metazard wrote:challenger410 wrote:In all honestly, I try not to be biased in jailing, whether it's my house, or some random guy who joined the server an hour before I logged on. I tend to look for more when it's my stuff being griefing, as opposed to just rolling back the other persons. I don't take lightly on griefing, which is why I usually grief, I say "You better hope you don't get caught by me", because I was a member for a very long time. I know how it feels to lose my stuff. I know how it feels having to rebuild time and time again, basically to the point to where you hide your home from everyone. I try to keep that off this server.
That hawkeye on my town 3 times tho
Challengecraft. NewChallengecraft, End challengecraft. Bossville,
rip bossville
Moral Dilemma - Qu3sti0nMark - 2014-03-15
Jamourous wrote:Hey Guys and Gals!
I wanted to gauge opinions on this popular dilemma, and the actual yay/nay persuasion of the community we are all a part of.
The rule in question is: Specific time periods for griefing a certain structure.
I personally agree with this, and so do a few other members of the community, while others believe in the 'if you don't protect it, it's your fault' rule. I use it only on my Farnsworth Houses, which are becoming more common in the landscape (There's 4 of them now, and 1 under construction). Griefing one (because all but one are unprotected) will result in a 10x worse punishment, as I like these houses, and I want to trust the community to be able to see these houses without protection. I saw a sign the other day saying 'grief results in a 12 day jail', which was brought to my attention by Jake, who removed 2 blocks, and I was halfway through the jail command before he put them back.
Heres the question: Do you agree? Should other people be allowed to jail for that extended time period if the structure is not theirs? Opinions, please.
Keep building!
Jack
ive had too many close calls.
and i wasnt trying to grief. i was trying to prove the point that if i were to break 2 blocks. is a 12 day jail neccesary and if he would go to that trouble. why cant he be screwed to mine 9 bits of lapis lazuli? it isnt that hard.
so in my opinion.. it is wrong.
it shouldnt happen
unless the person is known for griefing...